Important Background Information

Background on Dr. Ahmed Monis' fake Egyptian treatment/device C-Fast/CCD and Dr. Mohamed Fatouh and his Complaint
Background on Dr. Ahmed Monis' fake Egyptian treatment/device C-Fast/CCD
and Dr. Mohamed Fatouh and his Complaint

Monday, December 22, 2014

Background on the fake HIV/HCV device (C-Fast/CCD Complete Cure) and Dr. Mohamed Fatouh

Background on Dr. Ahmed Monis' fake Egyptian treatment/device C-Fast/CCD and Dr. Mohamed Fatouh and his Complaint
Background on Dr. Ahmed Monis' fake Egyptian treatment/device C-Fast/CCD
and Dr. Mohamed Fatouh and his Complaint

For background on the fake treatment/device:

Newly Added (7 Apr 2015)  :
  1. Egyptian Medical Syndicate: Statement on the interrogation of the perpetrators involved in military-announced #KoftaGate Fake HIV AIDS CCD C-Fast Device Cure
  2. Egyptian Medical Syndicate:  Statement confirming Non-Exclusion of any physician in virus cure device interrogations
  3. Testimony confirming the exclusion of the main interrogated perpetrator, Dr. Ahmed Monis (military-backed) from interrogations:
    - Almasry Alyoum Newspaper (Arabic) Article - 1, Article-2
    - Dr. Mohamed Fatouh (Arabic)
  4. Deutsche Welle (Arabic): Dr. Bassem Youssef on the military device: The biggest scientific scandal in Egypt history
  5. Huffington Post: Top Egyptian Comedian Slams Military For Saying It Can 'Cure' AIDS And Hepatitis C
  6. Trial of Dr. Mohamed Fatouh postponed for 11 April 2015 : Deciding on the appeal on the fine of $2700  (EGP 20,000)
  7. Bustle
 The original list:
  1. Science Mag: Expat virologist takes to YouTube to challenge 'pseudoscience' behind Egyptian devices
  2. NATURE MIDDLE EAST: The false science behind Egyptian army’s AIDS and HCV cure
  3. CNN: Egyptian army's AIDS-cure claim gets harsh criticism
  4. Ahram (Egypt): Claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C are a 'scandal': Egypt presidential advisor
  5. Egypt Independent (Egypt):  President orders review of AIDS-detecting device
  6. CairoPost(Egypt): President’s scientific adviser delays return to Egypt
  7. International Business Times: Egyptian Military Ridiculed over 'Cure for Aids'
  8. NYTimes: Disbelief After Egypt Announces Cures for AIDS and Hepatitis C
  9. Bustle: AIDS Cure Found By Egyptian Army, It Insists, So It's A Shame It's Almost Definitely A Scam [Many cross-reference links]
  10. McGill Daily SciTech : The state versus the expert Demarcating scientific authority
  11. Atlantic Council.: The Army’s Miracle Cure: Today’s Joke, Tomorrow’s Tragedy
  12. Egyptian Chronicles (blog): #KoftaGate : Dr. StrangeLove or how We Cured AIDS and HCV “Chapter-1” 
  13.  Egyptian Chronicles (blog): #KoftaGate : Dr. Strangelove or Trust Me I am a Doctor “Chapter-2” {Updated}
  14. Egyptian Chronicles (Egyptian blog) #KoftaGate : Let’s Burn those heretics at the Stake !! “Chapter3”
  15. The New Zealand Herald: Egypt's military delays device that 'cures' Aids amid ridicule
  16. The Telegraph: Egypt army embarrassment after it 'cures' Aids
  17. Mashable: Egypt's 'AIDS Curing Device' May Be A Fake Bomb Detector
  18. The Washington Times: Egypt’s army claims it found cure for AIDS, hepatitis C
  19. Egypt Independent: Forgive us Essam Heggy
  20. The Huffington Post: Top Egyptian Comedian Slams Military For Saying It Can 'Cure' AIDS And Hepatitis C
  21. Arabist: Kofta-Gate [Many cross-reference links]
  22. Pepijn van Erp. (blog): Update on #KoftaGate – Egyptian Miracle Detectors and Cures for Hepatitis C and AIDS  [Many cross-reference links]
  23.  The Quackometer Blog: Egyptian Government Duped by Nonsense HIV Detection Machine
  24. AMY MANTRAVADI: THE EGYPTIAN GOVERNMENT CURES AIDS!  [Many cross-reference links]
  25. The device international patent
  26. Guardian Liberty Voice: Egypt Army Claims to Have Cured AIDS, Hepatitis C
  27. The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy: Command and Consequence in a Strongman State
  28. NOW News. Mercury Media: No cure for pseudoscienceEgypt’s military “misusing science,” generating “false hopes,” says science writer
  29. Masress (news aggregator & index): Claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C are a 'scandal': Egypt presidential advisor
  30. El Balad (Egypt): Egyptian army delays rollout of ‘AIDS detecting machine’
  31. Al-Monitor: Egypt's 'kofta' scandal sign of missing checks, balances
  32. Egypt Independent (Egypt): Egyptian NASA scientist slams media disregard to space landing achievement
  33. Muftah: The Countdown to “Kofta Gate,” Egypt’s So-Called Cure for AIDS  [Many cross-reference links]
  34.  #BBCtrending: Egyptian public sceptical about military’s HIV ‘breakthrough’
  35. BuzzFeed: Why The Miracle Cure Offered To Egyptians With Hepatitis C Isn’t Funny
  36. Vice News: Egyptian Army Mocked for ‘Miracle’ AIDS CureShareTweet
  37. The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy: Koftagate: Dashed Hopes and Wasted Resources
  38. SF Gate: Egypt claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C
  39.  Comment Middle East: AIDS, HCV and Kofta The scientific comedy and the social moral tragedy
  40.  The Commentator: Egypt claims miracle cure for HIV and Hepatitis
  41. The Commentator: The big retreat. No Egypt HIV miracle cure after all
  42. Al Arabiya: Egypt’s army claims AIDS-detecting ‘scientific breakthrough’
  43.  Moftasa (blog): Update on the HIV & HCV miracle cure
  44. Moftasa (blog) : CC cures HIV/AIDS [cross-reference links]
For background on Dr. Mohamed Fatouh

  1. Dr. Fatouh Clinic on Facebook
  2. The Middle East Monitor :  Egyptian doctors continue strike, mass resignations
  3. firedoglake.com: Health Workers Deliver First Aid to Protest Movements
  4. Ahram Online: Tahrir doctors issue urgent appeal for colleagues to head to the square
  5. LA Times: Mosque becomes hospital for protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square
  6. Russia Today: At least 90 injured in Cairo as military close eyes on attack against protesters (PHOTOS)
  7. smke: Organizing a revolution: the Tahrir Doctors’ experience of using social media
  8. For a huge number of articles and reports, please make a google search on the sentence "Tahrir Doctors"
  9. Tahrir Doctors Society (founding member) : Website , Facebook, Youtube, Twitter
  10. Email
    mohamed_awad838@yahoo.com
    mfatouh838@gmail.com

    Facebook
    https://www.facebook.com/surgeon88
     

For background on Dr. Mohamed Fatouh' complaint


Ccomplete translation of Dr. Fatouh complaint document (The complaint
Dr. Mohamed Fatouh filed in the Egyptian Medical Syndicate Headquarter's Professional Ethics Department against Dr. Monis)

Translation:

In the name of Allah, The Merciful, The Compassionate

To Prof. Dr.: Head of Egyptian Medical Syndicate of Egypt
To Prof. Dr.: Head of Professional Ethics Department, Egyptian Medical
Syndicate of Egypt

I am presenting this complaint to you to investigate it, against Dr.
Ahmed Monis, Professor of Gastroenterology and Liver Diseases, Ain
Shams University, who is a registered doctor in the syndicate records,
for the following:

1 - He announced that he was part of invention of a device that he
claimed can treat many viral diseases, and conducted media marketing
to the same device in published, visual, and radio media without
reference to of any scientific tools, and known scientific research
procedures in the invention of the device, which resulted in harming
the reputation of Egyptian physicians inside and outside Egypt.

2- He willfully harmed the health of millions of Egyptian patients,
physically and psychologically, through participation in marketing the
device, which resulted in a portion of patients quitting their current
treatment, waiting for this alleged treatment to be available.

I ask you to investigate the causes of this complaint, and apply the
most severe penalties according to the Professional Ethics Regulations
against him if found guilty,to make him an example for anyone thinking
of harming the reputation of Egyptian physicians, or harming the
health of Egyptian patients for personal gains.

With high and due respect,

Presented by
Dr. Mohamed Fatouh Mohamed Awad
Surgery Consultant
Cairo Medical Syndicate Council member
President of Tahrir Doctors Society
Dated: 30/06/2014



For background on Dr. Ahmed Monis attack against Mohamed Fatouh in court

The lawsuit Dr. Ahmed Monis made against Dr. Fatouh for slander
and libel / defamation, concluding that:
- The complaint test contained false attributes to Dr. Monis like: "misleading the public" which is considered insults and defamation to the notable professor.
- Publishing of Dr. Fatouh's complaint on his own facebook wall, saying
under it "we will never have fears anymore, we will clean means we will clean" .. and giving the device the name "kofta device".. are defaming the device
and the professor.
(Kofta are Egyptian Arabic word for grilled bars of meat, the
spokesman of the team Dr. Ibrahim Abdel Atti said in the official
announcement:

"We will take AIDS from the patient, then made it a Kofta bar, then
give it back to the patient to feed on it"
For more information on the words "kofta" in that context of the device invention, please follow these search results: "kofta device doctor".



For background on Dr. Ahmed Monis 

General Ibrahim Abel Atti and Prof. Doctor Ahmed Monis with the claimed AIDS HIV/HCV Hepatitis deviceAhmed Monis is a  Professor of Gastroenterology and Liver Diseases, AinShams University
Dr. Ahmed Ali Monis Clinic website & personal information
- Twitter (not verified) :https://twitter.com/ahmedmonis
- Youtube (not verified) :https://www.youtube.com/user/ahmedmonis1/






Saturday, December 20, 2014

Documents: Science and Medicine sent to Court in Egypt

Readers of our blog sent us the following documents from Dr. Mohamed Fatouh friends to publish.

Documents include the complaint Dr. Fatouh filed in the Egyptian Medical Syndicate, and the lawsuit Dr. Ahmed Monis made against Dr. Fatouh, both in Arabic.
While No English translation available for now, we tried to translate the summary of the complaint.

First document:
The complaint Dr. Mohamed Fatouh filed in the Egyptian Medical Syndicate against the misleading practice of Dr. Ahmed Monis and propaganda he made in media for the untested and unverified C-Fast/CCD (Complete Cure Device) that he claimed can treat AIDS HIV, Hepatitis C HCV, and Cancer, and other diseases without any scientific basis. Something Dr. Fatouh saw as misleading and endangering Egyptian patients, and asked the Syndicate to investigate it.




Second document:
The three-page lawsuit Dr. Ahmed Monis made against Dr. Fatouh, accusing him of slander and libel.


First page:




Second page:




Third page:






وثائق قضية محاكمة العلم في مصر

أرسل أصدقاء المدونة إلينا اليوم هذه الوثائق عن محاكمة د. محمد فتوح بسبب دفاعه عن أصول العلم والمهنة الطبية وحق المريض في المعلومات الصحيحة


الوثائق:
شكوى د. محمد فتوح للنقابة ضد دعاية جهاز الإيدز
دعوى السبّ والقذف وتعويض 40 الف جنيه من د. أحمد مؤنس
(والتي تحتوي أيضا على سب وقذف (للإعلامي د. باسم يوسف - الصفحة الأخيرة)

أولا: صورة شكوى د. محمد فتوح المقدمة للنقابة



ثانيا: دعوى السبّ والقذف من د. أحمد مؤنس

صفحة اولى




صفحة ثانية



صفحة ثالثة


تضامنوا مع الدكتور محمد فتوح الطبيب المهدد بالسجن لدفاعه عن سمعة الطب وحقوق مرضى مصر

الدكتور/ محمد فتوح عوض.. مهدد بالحبس الآن




الطبيب المصري.. الدكتور/ محمد فتوح عوض.. مهدد بالحبس الآن!

د. محمد فتوح.. اسم يعرفه الكثير ممن شاركوا في ثورة يناير وامتداداتها. فهو من أول من شاركوا من الأطباء في إنقاذ مصابي الثورة، وكان مديرا وقائدا للمتطوعين في كثير من المستشفيات الميدانية في ثورة مصر

لم يكد د. محمد فتوح يعود من قافلة غزة للمساندة في إنقاذ مصابي العدوان الصهيوني على الفلسطينيين، حتى فوجئنا بأخبار سوداء عن استهداف طبيب اسمه أحمد يونس له بقضية في المحاكم، بسبب أنه تقدم بشكوى مهنية لنقابة الأطباء للتحقيق في تصريحات هذا الطبيب عن دواء يشفي من الأمراض الخطيرة التي عجز العالم أجمع على مدار عقود من التوصل لعلاج لها، وعلى رأسها: الإيدز وفيرس الالتهاب الكبدي الوبائي - سي

ورغم تضامن نقابة أطباء القاهرة، التي هو عضو بمجلس إدارتها المنتخب أيضا، معه.. فإن نقابة أطباء مصر لم تقم بالتحقيق ولم تقم بعمل أي جهد في سبيل التحقق من مصداقية هذا الاختراع الذي أعلتنه الهيئة الهندسية بالقوات المسلحة ، وهي جهة غير متخصصة في نفس الوقت ، وغير مسموح لها بإجراء أبحاث طبية أو الإعلان عن أدوية، فضلا عن عدم استيفاء هذا الاختراع للشروط الضرورية للإعلان عن أي دواء، وهو ما أكّده قائد جهاز الخدمات الطبية بالقوات المسلحة، فيما يشبه العودة للأصول المتعارف عليها، من أن الاختراع "مازال يحتاج مزيدا من الاختبارات".. وهو ما ليم يصرّح بمثله الدكتور أحمد مؤنس، ويبدو أنه لم يقتنع برأي الجيش، الذي هو نفسه مخترع الجهاز، ويتمهل في الدعاية والتسويق لعلاج لم تكتمل اختباراته، ويلتزم بتصريح القوات المسلحة.

لم يتوقف د. أحمد مؤنس عند هذا الحد، ولكنه قام برفع دعوى سب وقذف ضد د. محمد فتوح للانتقام الشخصي بسبب شكواه التي لم تقم النقابة بعمل اي شيء فيها حتى الان.


لم يشفع للدكتور محمد فتوح مغامرته بحياته لإنقاذ المصريين في أحداث يناير وموقعة الجمل ومحمد محمود ومجلس الوزراء وماسبيرو والاتحادية والمقطم وأحداث النهضة في مصر، ولا مساندته بنفسه للمستشفيات الميدانية في سوريا وغزة ودول أفريقيا، ولا حتى جهوده في تقديم الكثير من المبادرات لدعم حق المصريين في الصحة وإنشاء فرق مواجهة الكوارث، والمشاركة في قيادة اضراب الأطباء وتأسيس جمعية أطباء التحرير وخدمة العمل النقابي بالترشح والنجاح والعمل ضمن مجلس نقابة أطباء القاهرة..

لم تشفع للدكتور محمد فتوح كل أعماله الوطنية الجليلة.. في أن تثني د. أحمد مؤنس عن مهاجمته وتعمّد إضراره وأذيته.. لغرض غير مفهوم.. بدلا من الحوار المهني والعلمي الراقي.. داخل أروقة نقابة أطباء مصر.


ملحوظة: هذا المقال أرسله أحد محبي د. فتوح، وننشره كما هو دون تعديل.


لدعم د. محمد فتوح يمكنك مراسلته شخصيا:
إيميل
mohamed_awad838@yahoo.com
mfatouh838@gmail.com

فيس بوك
https://www.facebook.com/surgeon88

كما يمكنك المشاركة مع:

ايفنت دعم ومساندة د. محمد فتوح على الفيس بوك
https://www.facebook.com/events/399297793579535/

حملة مساندة الطبيب المضطهد في مصر
http://saveegyptdoctor.blogspot.com
تويتر
https://twitter.com/saveegyptdoctor
 

Friday, December 19, 2014

URGENT Save Egyptian Doctor from Prison and Egyptians from Scam

Saving lives.
starts with saving defenders of people's lives..


A human rights doctor is facing prison for just doing that:
Saving lives!

Dr. Mohamed Fatouh Awad filed a complaint in the General Egyptian Medical Syndicate against a doctor called Dr. Ahmed Monis, to investigate his wide propaganda marketing for the suspicious C-Fast and (CCD Complete Cure Device) announced few months ago by the Egyptian Armed Forces. This device has never been fully scientifically evaluated, while media reports linked it to a similar fake device sold last year in UK.

Prison is waiting Dr. Fatouh if convicted with slander and libel of Dr. Ahmed Monis, in a case he filed in court accusing Dr. Fatouh of slander-and-libel, as a reaction to the complaint Dr. Fatouh filed in the syndicate.
Final tribunal will be held in few days this week.


Cairo Medical Syndicate published a support statement last month, urging the General Syndicate to finish the investigation of Dr. Monis's claims, but nothing done to date.

Many scientists and doctors in and outside Egypt have reacted boldly against the announcement of this device before getting enough evaluation, the same thing Dr. Fatouh published in his criticism on Facebook and in his complaint presented to the Medical Syndicate.

As a notable human rights and patient rights defender, field-hospitals leader in 2011 Tahrir Egyptian revolution, and health system reform advocate, Dr. Mohamed Fatouh is now in danger of getting imprisoned for just defending other's rights to not be scammed by immature and unsafe medical pharmaceutical treatments.

If you need more information , please contact Dr. Fatouh directly at:

Email:
mohamed_awad838@yahoo.com
mfatouh838@gmail.com
Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/surgeon88


You also may be interested in joining our event and petition here:
Event:
https://www.facebook.com/events/399297793579535/?ref=29&ref_notif_type=like&source=1



Thank you for your cooperation,

References:

For background on the fake treatment/device:

  1. Science Mag: Expat virologist takes to YouTube to challenge 'pseudoscience' behind Egyptian devices
  2. NATURE MIDDLE EAST: The false science behind Egyptian army’s AIDS and HCV cure
  3. CNN: Egyptian army's AIDS-cure claim gets harsh criticism
  4. Ahram (Egypt): Claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C are a 'scandal': Egypt presidential advisor
  5. CairoPost(Egypt): President’s scientific adviser delays return to Egypt
  6. International Business Times: Egyptian Military Ridiculed over 'Cure for Aids'
  7. NYTimes: Disbelief After Egypt Announces Cures for AIDS and Hepatitis C
  8. Bustle: AIDS Cure Found By Egyptian Army, It Insists, So It's A Shame It's Almost Definitely A Scam [Many cross-reference links]
  9. McGill Daily SciTech : The state versus the expert Demarcating scientific authority
  10. Atlantic Council.: The Army’s Miracle Cure: Today’s Joke, Tomorrow’s Tragedy
  11. Egyptian Chronicles (Egyptian blog) #KoftaGate : Let’s Burn those heretics at the Stake !! “Chapter3”
  12. The New Zealand Herald: Egypt's military delays device that 'cures' Aids amid ridicule
  13. The Telegraph: Egypt army embarrassment after it 'cures' Aids
  14.  Mashable: Egypt's 'AIDS Curing Device' May Be A Fake Bomb Detector
  15. The Washington Times: Egypt’s army claims it found cure for AIDS, hepatitis C
  16. Egypt Independent: Forgive us Essam Heggy
  17. The Huffington Post: Top Egyptian Comedian Slams Military For Saying It Can 'Cure' AIDS And Hepatitis C
  18. Arabist: Kofta-Gate [Many cross-reference links]
  19. Pepijn van Erp. (blog): Update on #KoftaGate – Egyptian Miracle Detectors and Cures for Hepatitis C and AIDS  [Many cross-reference links]
  20.  The Quackometer Blog: Egyptian Government Duped by Nonsense HIV Detection Machine
  21.  AMY MANTRAVADI: THE EGYPTIAN GOVERNMENT CURES AIDS!  [Many cross-reference links]
  22.  The device international patent
  23. Guardian Liberty Voice: Egypt Army Claims to Have Cured AIDS, Hepatitis C
  24. The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy: Command and Consequence in a Strongman State
  25. NOW News. Mercury Media: No cure for pseudoscienceEgypt’s military “misusing science,” generating “false hopes,” says science writer
  26. Masress (news aggregator & index): Claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C are a 'scandal': Egypt presidential advisor
  27. El Balad (Egypt): Egyptian army delays rollout of ‘AIDS detecting machine’
  28. Al-Monitor: Egypt's 'kofta' scandal sign of missing checks, balances
  29. Egypt Independent (Egypt): Egyptian NASA scientist slams media disregard to space landing achievement
  30. Muftah: The Countdown to “Kofta Gate,” Egypt’s So-Called Cure for AIDS  [Many cross-reference links]
  31.  #BBCtrending: Egyptian public sceptical about military’s HIV ‘breakthrough’
  32. BuzzFeed: Why The Miracle Cure Offered To Egyptians With Hepatitis C Isn’t Funny
  33. Vice News: Egyptian Army Mocked for ‘Miracle’ AIDS CureShareTweet
  34.   The Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy: Koftagate: Dashed Hopes and Wasted Resources
  35. SF Gate: Egypt claims of cure for HIV, Hepatitis C
  36.  Comment Middle East: AIDS, HCV and Kofta The scientific comedy and the social moral tragedy
For background on Dr. Mohamed Fatouh
  1. Tahrir Doctors Society (founder of) : Website , Facebook, Youtube, Twitter
  2. Dr. Fatouh Clinic on Facebook
  3. The Middle East Monitor :  Egyptian doctors continue strike, mass resignations
  4. firedoglake.com: Health Workers Deliver First Aid to Protest Movements
  5. Ahram Online: Tahrir doctors issue urgent appeal for colleagues to head to the square
  6. LA Times: Mosque becomes hospital for protesters in Cairo's Tahrir Square
  7. Russia Today: At least 90 injured in Cairo as military close eyes on attack against protesters (PHOTOS)
  8. smke: Organizing a revolution: the Tahrir Doctors’ experience of using social media
  9. For a huge number of articles and reports, please make a google search on the sentence "Tahrir Doctors"

For more information (in Arabic, you can translate using online translation/Google):

Statement of Support by Cairo Medical Syndicate:
http://www.ems.org.eg/l3.php?id=2411

News story about the case:
http://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/605506


Join us on Twiter:
https://twitter.com/saveegyptdoctor